Wild Montana v. Gianforte
On May 1, 2023, the Legislature passed Senate Bill 442—an overwhelmingly bipartisan, politically popular measure that directs recreational marijuana tax revenues to conservation and recreation programs, local infrastructure projects, and veterans’ services. Of 150 legislators, 130 voted to pass SB 442. The next day, the Governor vetoed the bill, but the Senate adjourned before the veto was communicated to the full Senate.
When the Governor vetoes a bill passed by a supermajority of legislators after the Legislature has adjourned, the Constitution requires that the Secretary poll the Legislature by mail. Normally, the Governor returns the bill with his reasons for veto to the Secretary, triggering the post-adjournment override process. When the Governor failed to take that step, Wild Montana—a nonprofit grassroots conservation organization that unites and mobilizes communities to keep Montana wild—and the Montana Wildlife Federation—Montana's oldest, largest, and most effective wildlife conservation organization—called on the Governor to uphold the Montana Constitution and return the bill to the Secretary. The Governor refused.
Wild Montana and the Montana Wildlife Federation filed suit to compel Governor Greg Gianforte and Secretary of State Christi Jacobsen to comply with their obligations under the Montana Constitution and allow the Montana Legislature the opportunity to override the Governor’s veto of SB 442.
Filings / Press
Petition (June 7, 2023)
Seaborn Larson, Conservation groups sue Gianforte over veto dispute, Independent Record (June 7, 2023)
Arren Kimbel-Sannit, Conservation groups, counties sue to give lawmakers ability to override veto of marijuana revenue bill, Montana Free Press (June 7, 2023)
Darrell Ehrlick, Second lawsuit filed alleges Gianforte used ‘procedural trickery’ to stop popular marijuana bill, Daily Montanan (June 7, 2023)
Meridith Depping, Suit claims Gov. Gianforte did not follow post-adjournment veto override procedure, ABC Montana (June 7, 2023)
Ellis Juhlin, The governor's handling of a marijuana tax bill triggers lawsuits, MTPR (June 8, 2023)
Secretary's Motion to Dismiss (July 14, 2023)
Secretary's Brief in Support (July 14, 2023)
Petitioners' and Plaintiffs' Brief in Opposition (July 31, 2023)
Secretary's Reply in Support (Aug. 18, 2023)
Governor's Motion to Dismiss (Aug. 18, 2023)
Governor's Brief in Support (Aug. 18, 2023)
Petitioners' and Plaintiffs' Brief in Opposition (Sep. 1, 2023)
Governor's Reply in Support (Sep. 25, 2023)
Wild Montana & MACo's Joint Motion for Summary Judgment (Sep. 1, 2023)
Brief in Support (Sep. 1, 2023)
Secretary's Brief in Opposition (Oct. 2, 2023)
Reply in Support (Oct. 23, 2023)
Governor's Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment (Oct. 2, 2023)
Plaintiffs' & Petitioners' Brief in Opposition (Oct. 23, 2023)
Governor's Reply in Support (Nov. 9, 2023)
Order Denying Defendants' Motions to Dismiss (Jan. 16, 2024)
Order Granting Plaintiffs' and Petitioners' Motion for Summary Judgment (Jan. 16, 2024)
Darrell Ehrlick, Judge says Legislature must be given an opportunity to override governor’s veto of SB 442, Daily Montanan (Jan. 16, 2024)
Court mandates governor, secretary of state allow SB 442 veto override vote, NBC Montana (Jan. 16, 2024)
Jonathon Ambarian, Judge rules lawmakers should get chance to vote on Gianforte's late veto, KTVH (Jan. 16, 2024)
Governor's Motion to Stay Judgment (Feb. 6, 2024)
Brief in Support (Feb. 6, 2024)
Petitioner and Plaintiffs' Brief in Opposition (Feb. 20, 2024)
Order Denying Motion to Stay (Mar. 5, 2024)
Governor's Appeal of Stay Denial (Mar. 13, 2024)
Secretary's Motion to Stay (Mar. 13, 2024)
Order Denying Secretary's Motion to Stay (Mar. 14, 2024)
Montana Supreme Court Order Affirming Denial of Stay (Mar. 15, 2024)